Bringing back Tansu Çiller

Why, oh why, could anyone possibly think that this is a good idea?

Tansu ÇillerWhy, oh why, could anyone possibly think that this is a good idea?

Part of the government in Britain, where I appear to be invariably based at the moment, seems obsessed with dispensing with its prime minister after less than a year in the job. “We’re not popular, we’ll probably lose the next election, it’s not working out for us,” they mutter behind closed doors, before adding: “Off with his head and bring in a new one.” Or something to that effect.

The instinct in Turkey is precisely the opposite. When things go wrong, the prevailing mood is one of either stagnation or regression. Stagnation is the case with the Republican People’s Party (CHP), which recently re-elected its directionless leader, unopposed, in an appalling example of democracy (see my outdated entry on the CHP for some back story). Regression appears to be what is happening to the Democrat Party (DP), which is trying to bring back its former leader and last prime minister, Tansu Çiller.

Mrs Çiller assumed the vacant post of prime minister in 1993, after Süleyman Demirel moved up to the presidency. She wasn’t particularly high-ranking – a mere state minister, certainly not senior in the cabinet – and she contested her party’s leadership against such heavyweights as İsmet Sezgin and Köksal Toptan. Her victory was credited largely to Turkey’s media, including the fledgling private television channels, which made much of the idea of a first woman prime minister.

If you asked her what her greatest achievement in office was, she would probably tell you it was that Turkey entered a Customs Union with the European Union under her watch. Or that the military’s funding was stepped up to combat the mounting PKK threat. She wouldn’t be one to talk of the banking crisis of the early 1990s, her alleged corrupt practices (including tenders that favoured her wealthy businessman husband), or the fact that she never won a election.

Mrs Çiller was a staggeringly ineffective leader. Under her, the party won a successively smaller share of the vote, finally failing to cross the electoral threshold in 2002. Her first election, in 1995, saw her lose to Necmettin Erbakan’s Welfare Party (RP). It was a shock to Turkey’s secular establishment for the overtly religious RP to do so well; what shocked them more was Mrs Çiller joining them in coalition. During the campaign, she had declared Mr Erbkaban “a smuggler of heroin” and herself “the safeguard of secularism”, but after six months and a hefty libel fee the two leaders were in a “power rotating” scheme whereby Mr Erbakan would be prime minister first, and Mrs Çiller would follow in a year-and-a-half.

She stood silent as her senior partner spurned the west and made highly publicised visits to Iran and Libya. She was genuinely surprised, upon Mr Erbakan’s resignation, not to be asked to form the next government. She was not a good leader, and now her old rump party wants her back.

To bring back a former, supposedly succesful leader is a delusional byword for political recovery in Turkey. Party leaders are effectively sanctified in the country – most party conventions, for instance, will feature large portraits of both Atatürk and the present leader – and they are a rallying point for genuine enthusiasm and unwavering loyalty. During a recent parliamentary debate on smoking bans, one Nationalist Action Party (MHP) MP spoke passionately about the charismatic style with which his leader, Devlet Bahçeli, could hold and smoke a cigarette. He was probably not even planted.

This near-blind degree of loyalty makes it somewhat easier to understand why Turkish parties tend not to blame their leaders for electoral failure. But it is still delusional: parties don’t to recognise it even when the public have had enough of them. In the 1999 elections, having failed to cross the ten percent threshold to win seats in parliament, Mr Baykal resigned. It was widely hailed as an act of political maturity, but he was back in just six months. Mr Bahçeli, Mrs Çiller and Motherland Party leader Mesut Yılmaz all made similar pledges when their parties failed to cross the threshold in 2002; with this latest offer to Mrs Çiller, all have now returned to politics.

Turks have a long tradition of sanctifying their leaders. Any tourist to Turkey will tell you Kemal Atatürk is an obvious example, but it applies to more recent leaders too: the late Bülent Ecevit ousted CHP leader and War of Independence veteran Ismet İnönü in 1973. İnönü had been leader for thirty-five years, and Ecevit was widely credited with ending what was effectively a theocracy. But that same cult of personality came to apply to Ecevit, and it would be twenty-nine years before he was toppled himself.

Few outside the DP will celebrate Mrs Çiller’s return. It will do little for the party’s electability, as its traditional centre-right base has long been subsumed by the ruling AK Party. But it does have wider implications for Turkish politics: a year ago, I wrote that AK’s electoral victory, while welcome, urgently needed to be balanced by an effective opposition. With stagnation in the CHP and regression in the DP, it does not appear to be happening. And that is not good for Turkey.

blogspot visit counter
  1. She hasn’t made a comeback and isn’t likely to.So this blog was unnecessary. You see everything in terms of personalities, but there are deeper causes for the stagnation in Turkish politics you detect. One is Islamisation. Another is the excessive subsidies paid to political parties. A third is the the fact that party leaders in Turkey have had total control for the last two decades of the party lists of candidates at general elections.

  2. Thanks-a-mundo for the post.Really thank you! Much obliged.

  3. “Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point. You definitely know what youre talking about, why waste your intelligence on just posting videos to your weblog when you could be giving us something informative to read?”

  4. Awesome blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere?
    A design like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog shine.
    Please let me know where you got your design. With thanks

  5. Simply desire to say your article is as astounding.
    The clarity on your post is simply excellent and that i can assume you’re an expert in this subject.
    Well along with your permission let me to snatch your feed to stay up to
    date with imminent post. Thanks a million and please keep up the rewarding

  6. I’ve been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or weblog posts on this kind of house .
    Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this
    web site. Reading this info So i am glad to exhibit that I’ve a very just right uncanny feeling I found out
    exactly what I needed. I such a lot no doubt will make certain to do not omit this website and
    give it a look on a continuing basis.

  7. Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
    The words in your article seem to be running off the screen in Ie.

    I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with
    browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know.
    The design look great though! Hope you get the problem fixed soon. Cheers

  8. Good day! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after checking through
    some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m definitely happy I found it
    and I’ll be book-marking and checking back often!

  9. Please note, that due to the fact, that the vast majority of software applications install additional components on your PC, the free version of the software tools may include latest updates, add-ons and additional components, of which you may not have known.1. Technical Field
    The present invention relates to a photoselective compound, an organic light-emitting diode including the same, a method of manufacturing the organic light-emitting diode, and a display device including

    6add127376 crosanys

  10. As the program does not require any registration and can be freely downloaded for free, here is a short instructional video that will let you have a better understanding of how to use this fine tool.

    Taoist V.P.N 7.5 Beta running on Windows 2003/XP/2000/98/ME/95

    – People working for the security company (e.g. cyber-security specialist)
    – People

    6add127376 winezyto

  11. Flash PSD Template with designs for hero elements and informational texts. Includes 3 versions (All, Text, Hero), and 2 color schemes (Colored and White) in all layers. Use if you want to build a visually stunning slideshows or footers with simple text, photos, icons and trailers. Contains all the necessary graphics and assets to start your project immediately.

    Flash PSD Template with designs for hero elements and informational texts. Includes 3 versions (All, Text,

    6add127376 isaches

  12. The desktop version of the software comes with no informative advertisements and uses BitTorrent for all downloads. It’s an easy, free option if podcast downloading is new to you.
    How to download a podcast in 30 seconds
    Podcast Downloader is meant to be a quick and easy way to download podcasts. It is easy to configure and takes no time to work. Despite lacking some features and being powered by BitTorrent, it does a decent job of organizing your podcasts.
    The only downside to

    6add127376 jasgavr

  13. XLX is a powerful, feature-rich and high-quality virtualization software designed to offer a seamless virtual computing experience to Windows, Linux and OS X users. It represents the consolidation of various desktop virtualization solutions available, including a next-generation graphical interface, a full-fledged virtual operating system and an installation and boot manager.
    A native Intel virtualization technology, XLX offers full hardware acceleration and supports features like Intel VT-x, Intel VT-d, Intel P-state and Turbo Boost. It also supports hardware virtualization for Intel and AMD chipsets. It is designed from the ground-up to work

    6add127376 orazmaeg

  14. Buying and selling links is not everyone’s cup of tea, and that is why we developed the Backlinks Submission Toolkit, a full-fledged program that not only easily teaches you how to spot and earn a backlink, but how to uncover more of them by auction.
    The Toolkit offers you the latest information on back links, including:
    * How to make profit
    * How to build a cash-flow
    * How to avoid the risks
    * How to optimize the system

    6add127376 gercons

  15. It remains small in size and instant. It can be launched from your desktop and has a quick access bar on the top. It requires minimal resources out there and offers quick and easy task-oriented features that go far beyond a single radio station feature offered by other products and programs. It is actively supported by the Yahoo! Widget Engine as it comes with a standard WYSIWYG (what you see is what you get) composition editor. And lastly, it gives you the chance

    6add127376 rozenaro

  16. It offers instructions for every basic and advanced operation it offers, allowing both beginners and computer-savvy users alike to easily login.
    Best Free Viber Ringtone Downloader : Download Viber Ringtone From Pocket PC
    On the go? Download Viber ringtones for free
    Yesterday, we have posted an overview of Viber – the most popular VoIP Mobile Phone App which allows you to make free phone calls, send free messages and much more using a nice and sleek user interface. Additionally

    6add127376 aureonta

  17. It is important to update the RealPlayer plugin in the following manner:
    – Open the RealPlayer menu.
    – Select Plugins.
    – You should see OGG Plugin in the list.
    – Select the item and it should install.
    The user may be asked to confirm the plugin installation.
    As soon as it has been installed it should be listed under the RealPlayer menu and under Plugin menu under Modify menu. For further instructions and installation see the plugin information page.

    6add127376 nandel

  18. Full Disclosure:
    I did a project for sharplight in May 2011. To give credit where it is due, I want to give a positive review of not only sharplight, but also of Project Dispatch so the ball is rolling for that one as well. This review will be useful to those considering their first license purchase for their industry.

    Project Dispatch
    Project Dispatch is a python server that allows for each web service (say

    6add127376 gellyso

  19. You can load the recording into another program and easily see the spectrogram.
    Also, anabat-compatible files can be opened with any wave editor since the files contain all the necessary information to create the file.
    zero-crossings that had an mean-offset value of more than 1 will be ignored, so all detected zero-crossings should produce audio that is directly compatible to anabats.
    how it looks:


    I’m also not sure

    6add127376 yitroza

  20. It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it’s time to be happy.
    I’ve read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you some interesting things or tips.
    Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article.
    I want to read even more things about it!

  21. Note: the trial version of File Marker is completely free and features a single catalog entry feature and a convenient configuration panel.

    Mac OS X (certain versions)

    Mac OS X (10.3.9) is no longer supported. Technical support is no longer offered. Newer versions of Mac OS X can be installed on supported System 6, System 7, and System 8 computers, with 10.3.9 or later. Check the article on Mac OS X
    66cf4387b8 saclaw

  22. ■ For Opera, Netscape 6/7, and Mozilla the Plug-In also requires the Add-ons/Plug-In menu option within your web browser.
    ■ The “external program for Firefox” feature will only work in Firefox/Mozilla.
    If your versions of Opera, Netscape, or Mozilla were too old to have the “Open with External Program” added, download the latest version of the GetRight Plug-In and try again.
    66cf4387b8 olivgent

  23. It has a simple graphical interface and you can record and visually enter musical data by tapping a few buttons or using the keyboard’s QWERTY keyboard.

    If you’ve been keeping an eye out for more great new iPad apps, you can click here for a collection of my other favorites as well.

    More Value for Less Money

    Speaking of budgets, since the program is free, not only does it have more features but the price is even much more
    ec5d62056f nirvhar

  24. We recommend it for conversion of graphics in static presentations, rather than working with images that undergo frequent changes.


    Unlike the other conversion programs in our list, the conversion procedure is as easy as selecting the TIFF file or folder to convert and the destination directory or folder.
    Just enter the new location of the generated DOCX files and the output name as well as the documents’ page margins, page size, number of pages and others, in the output options.

    ec5d62056f berngast

  25. The interface is intuitive, doesn’t get in your way and is lightweight and portable. It’ll easily be your new standard alarm clock.
    I have been using it for seven months, and the developers have made sure that they solve all the current problems. The application’s current version is, and you can download it from SourceForge.

    6. Alarm-Clock Free download – Alarm Clock Free is an application that allows users to schedule and sound the
    ec5d62056f hamrayd

  26. The data will include the URL of the accessed page.
    Safeguard your PC
    Our Control Panel is a wrapper around several popular software apps that have been specially designed to give you more control over your computer. It’s like having an inbuilt spyware detector on your computer.
    Data analysis
    The display updates every 10 seconds to show the result of any update on the domain / IP address you’re looking for. You get the Where Am I map on the top
    ec5d62056f brigar

  27. As expected, all these features are available in other text editors out there, so SavageEd just doesn’t provide much more than most of its competitors, which are definitely more user-friendly. Even if they lack some nice looking and ultra-functioning text editors, it is definitely worth mentioning that their price falls under $20, so basically, they come at a very good price compared to SavageEd.
    One excellent example would be the ZEN Text Editor (ZenTextEditor.
    ec5d62056f tamigni

  28. Actually, as a standalone app, it is a very small download of only 1 MB.
    Furthermore, the requirements for the installation are as simple as they can get. The installer is simple and you may have to wait for a while to get it ready, but after five minutes, you should have the app ready and installed.

    Picture Algorithm

    Not nearly as fun as you expect it to be, but it’s a great little algorithm for quickly creating a series of pictures that will
    ec5d62056f vytursi

  29. It has all the features that one would want a software to offer, and for the purpose of doing business management, it gives you what you need by default.

    Is your small company about to run into money problems? Then an accounting software for small business might be the answer to your prayers. The fact is, small businesses often run into technical and downright money problems and there is a wide variety of software out there that can help you from crisis to crisis. While the professionals from the ICA
    ec5d62056f andrkeal

  30. The Greek courses are designed to ensure that you learn a respectable range of common everyday words and phrases, allowing you to communicate effectively with no problem.
    eLearning solutions for the enterprise, from Content Marketing to Digital PR, Digital Learning, Digital Experience, Sales, Management, Training, and much more. Salesforce Content has helped hundreds of clients and tens of thousands of business users to grow their business faster in the cloud. Ever wish you could divide your customer base into different segments based on interest in
    ec5d62056f asteshan

  31. Best calculator for Windows 10 / Linux, Mac, Windows Phone /…

    Aerosoft VP-62 Eurofighter Typhoon UHD Edition (79 Mb)

    An ideal flight simulator with more than 450 planes to fly, 25 and 40 missions and two users. AirCombat detects obstacles and planes using a detailed 3D engine at 90 frames per second. The gaming on the object through the player can create any kind of situation for the planning and the maneuvering of the plane. On the
    ec5d62056f yornisb

  32. Technical Field
    The present disclosure relates to information display devices, and particularly to an information display device with an audio playing function and a sensing and display device.
    Description of the Related Art
    With the development of technology, electronic products are commonly multi-functional devices, such as computers, smartphones, mobile phones, mobile information devices, etc., and people have increasing needs for using various types of data at different locations. In order to satisfy these needs, the electronic products are designed to be portable or
    ec5d62056f parlprym

  33. It can also copy data across systems for you if that’s your cup of tea.

    RAR file viewer is similar to WinZip, WinRAR, WinZIP or WinARC, but it’s a freeware and open source for Linux desktop. It’s a powerful tool for handling the widely used RAR and ZIP archive formats, with interfaces, powerful RAR or ZIP extractors, file previewer (or compressor), archive contents unpacker, enclosure content extractor, zip
    ec5d62056f keathor


    SoundHound may be all the rage these days but it has been around for quite some time now. It serves as the heart and soul of your smartphone making voice recognition and voice-matched searches so easy. With a lot of things to take care of, the Berlin-based company that owns it has decided to rebrand SoundHound and rename it Houndify.

    Rebranding and renaming, yes, but this isn’t
    ec5d62056f fidchur

  35. Aw, this was a very nice post. In thought I wish to put in writing like this moreover – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article… however what can I say… I procrastinate alot and not at all appear to get something done.

  36. I don’t even understand how I stopped up here, but I believed this put up used to be great.

    I don’t recognise who you might be however certainly you are going to a
    famous blogger if you happen to are not already.